TABLEĀ 4

Statistical methods and reporting in the evaluated journals

Respiratory journalsNEJM+LancetSelected medical journalsAll articlesp-value of Chi-squared test
Total articles n160320360840
Statistical methods described100 (62.5)219 (68.4)221 (61.4)540 (64.3)0.140
Reference to statistical literature38 (23.8)144 (45.0)104 (28.9)286 (34.0)<0.001
Statistical software reported126 (78.8)191 (59.7)215 (59.7)532 (63.3)<0.001
Comparing groups111 (69.4)221 (69.1)199 (55.3)531 (63.2)<0.001
Repeated measurements18 (11.3)35 (10.9)36 (10.0)89 (10.6)0.884
Correlation coefficient methods38 (23.8)25 (7.8)75 (20.8)138 (16.4)<0.001
Regression models96 (60.0)205 (64.1)165 (45.8)466 (55.5)<0.001
Other multivariable methods9 (5.6)13 (4.1)35 (9.7)57 (6.8)0.010
Intra-cluster correlation methods24 (15.0)58 (18.1)57 (15.8)139 (16.5)0.614
Measures of agreement27 (16.9)31 (9.7)69 (19.2)127 (15.1)0.002
Bayesian methods1 (0.6)5 (1.6)4 (1.1)10 (1.2)0.712
ANN or machine learning02 (0.6)02 (0.2)0.181

Data are presented as n (%), unless stated otherwise. NEJM: New England Journal of Medicine; ANN: artificial neural networks.