TABLE 3

Equivalence test for the three methods and comparison of the paired results (McNemar test)

p-value (McNemar test)Difference90% CI95% CI
Haemophilus influenzae
 OP/CP-SP0.014−5.4−10.5 to −0.3#−11.5 to 0.7#
 OP/CP-OP0.144−2.5−7.4 to 2.5−8.4 to 3.4
 CP-SP/CP-OP0.1942.9−2.3 to 8.2−3.3 to 9.2
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
 OP/CP-SP0.003−5.5−10.0 to −1.1#−10.8 to −0.2#
 OP/CP-OP0.029−3.1−7.3 to 1.1−8.1 to 2.0
 CP-SP/CP-OP0.1442.4−2.2 to 7.1−3.1 to 8.0
Staphylococcus aureus
 OP/CP-SP0.159−3.7−10.5 to 3.0#−11.8 to 4.3#
 OP/CP-OP0.262−2.4−9.1 to 4.4−10.4 to 5.7#
 CP-SP/CP-OP0.4661.4−5.4 to 8.1−6.7 to 9.4

Differences, 90% confidence intervals and 95% confidence intervals are presented as %. OP: oropharyngeal swab; CP-SP: chest physiotherapy session followed by a provoked cough to obtain sputum; CP-OP: second oropharyngeal swab collected after chest physiotherapy. #: confidence interval outside −10% to +10% (i.e. 90% CI) or −5% to +5% (i.e. 95% CI) signifying that the methods are not equivalent. p<0.05 indicates statistical significance.